Skip to main content

Active

215 E Church Street

Tarboro, NC 27886 · Edgecombe County

241 days on market
$365,000
Was $395,000
$365,000Tarboro (Town Limits)$250K – $500KHistoricUnder $375KActive
365000
Price Reduced
5 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
3,844 Sq.Ft.
0.14 Acres
Built in 1925
Historic Built 19252 FireplacesTarboro District

About This Property

**Income Potential with separate apartment** This charming home can be found in the Historic district, downtown Tarboro and is noted on the historic district map as Lichtenstein-Thigpen House. The national registry plaque identifies it as Cotton-Lichtenstein House ca.1875. The current owner has an eye for design and classic style and they have brought this 'old home' back to life! Just a few minutes' walk to downtown amenities including shops and restaurants. The signature front porch that overlooks a city sidewalk creates opportunities to enjoy your community every day! The main 2 story living space (*2652 sq.ft) includes 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, open sitting area upstairs and features a large foyer downstairs that can serve as a reception hall or parlor, a formal dining, family room, 1 bedroom, 1 full bath, laundry room and an amazing kitchen with a large island that draws you to the heart of this home! The updated cabinetry features a pantry wall and granite counter tops. In addition, there is a large walk-in pantry, stainless appliances with an authentic old fireplace structure to complement this space. This home is ideal for multi-generational living with the additional living quarters (1192 sq ft.) on the main level with private entrance. It is perfect as an in-law suite or an income producing apartment and includes 1 bedroom, 1 full bath, a full kitchen with laundry, a spacious living area, a small flex room that would be great for a home office. There are fireplaces in most rooms that add so much character to this beautiful home, however, most were used in days gone by systems that are now obsolete. Other improvements include a roof replacement (2019), 2 new Gas packs (2017), 2 new electric hot water heaters (2017), and full exterior paint (2025). Book your appt. today! *Total living space square footage is 3844 Squ ft. The primary living space is 2652 squ foot (Upstairs is cooled but not heated). There is a possibility that this could be converted into 3 separate living spaces based on historical use.

Price History & Market Timeline

Original List Price$395,000
Current List Price (Price Reduced)$365,000Reduced by $30,000

Property Details

SubdivisionHistoric District
TypeSingle Family Residence
Living Area3,844 sq ft
Full Baths3
Price / sq ft$95
Lot Size0.140 acres
Year Built1925
Total Rooms11
Fireplaces2
WaterfrontNo
Parcel473845434400

Location & Neighborhood Intelligence

Get Directions to This Home

Distance to Key Places (straight-line)

Coastal & Environmental Information

Properties in Edgecombe County may sit within mapped FEMA flood zones, within a municipal historic district overlay requiring a Certificate of Appropriateness, or both. Buyers are advised to independently verify flood zone, elevation, substantial-damage history and flood insurance requirements with the county floodplain administrator, a licensed surveyor and an insurance professional before relying on anything shown here.

Interior & Exterior

FlooringLVT/LVP, Laminate, Wood, Hardwood, Other
HeatingGas Pack, Electric, Natural Gas
CoolingCentral Air
RoofArchitectural Shingle
ConstructionWood Siding, Wood Frame
StyleHistoric District
AppliancesBuilt-In Microwave, Washer, Refrigerator, Dryer, Dishwasher, Electric Range
ParkingOn Street

Interior Features

Walk-in Closet(s)High CeilingsEntrance FoyerSolid SurfaceKitchen IslandApt/SuitePantryBasementWalk-In Closet(s)

Schools

ElementaryStocks
MiddlePatillo
High SchoolTarboro

Tax & Assessment

Assessed Value$293,363
Annual Tax$3,843 (2026)
Monthly Tax Est.$320/mo
Hyper-Local Buyer Tool

Tarboro True Cost of Ownership Calculator

Calculate your actual monthly carrying cost — including Edgecombe County taxes, Town municipal rates, your own flood insurance quote, and historic district reserves.

$365,000
5%

Tap a marker for the exact program, or drag freely for any other amount. Snaps to 0% (USDA/VA), 3.5% (FHA), 5% (Conventional) and 20% (no PMI).

Local Tax & Municipal Variables
Edgecombe County TaxEdgecombe County charges $0.89 per $100 of assessed value for fiscal year 2026-2027 (adopted June 22, 2026). Verify with the local tax office.
Active
Applies additional $0.4750 / $100 municipal tax. Switch off for county-only parcels outside town.
Adds $150/mo reserve for custom wood, slate/metal roof & COA maintenance
Property along the Tar River and its tributaries falls into mapped FEMA flood zones. Your zone determines whether a federally backed lender requires flood insurance — we don't quote rates, so enter your own insurer's written quote below.

Enter your actual annual quote and we'll amortize it into your monthly cost. Leave blank and it's excluded entirely.

$0

Finance repair scope directly into mortgage via FHA 203(k) or Fannie Mae HomeStyle loan.

Estimated Monthly True Cost
$0
Includes P&I, taxes, insurance & local reserves
  • Principal & Interest$0
  • Edgecombe County Property Tax ($0.89)$0
  • Town of Tarboro Municipal Tax ($0.4750)$0
  • Hazard / Homeowners Insurance (Est.)$0
  • Flood Insurance (Your Quote)$0
  • Historic Overlay COA Reserve$0
  • PMI / Mortgage Insurance$0
Total Loan Amount$0
Down Payment$0
Review True Cost Breakdown with Travis

Get exact contractor & tax quotes verified before you write an offer.

MLS# 100553309 · HIVE MLS via SourceRE · Last updated: October 25, 2026 at 7:05 AM UTC. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Horizon Realty Group.